Many organizations are turning to Chocolatey to manage their Windows packages, and for good reason. Chocolatey allows sysadmins to manage packages completely via the command-line interface (CLI), allowing them to automate the creation, installation, and uninstallation of packages.

If an organization is serious about using Chocolatey to manage its packages, then it really should host its own package repository. Of course, you could use the public Chocolatey repository as your source for packages, but this is a bad idea for a couple of reasons. First, you would have to trust the maintainers of those packages completely, and second, you would need to reach out to the internet to install the packages.

Fortunately, Chocolatey for Business (C4B) allows you to recompile (or internalize) public packages easily, which then enables you to push these packages to your own repository. Internalizing refers to taking remote installers that public packages may call, downloading them, and then embedding them in your NuGet package or another location such as a CIFS share.

When I created my own repository, one of the first tasks I looked at automating was internalizing public packages—especially since I manage hundreds of packages. Doing this has saved me countless hours creating my own packages. The initial internalizing of packages from Chocolatey is actually quite simple, as I will show below, but what happens when a new package version is released? This is where PowerShell comes in handy.

In this article, I will demonstrate how to check for updated Chocolatey packages, test installation, and internalize them automatically. Keep in mind this is done with the Chocolatey Business version, which significantly eases the process.

How Chocolatey internalizing works

Internalizing essentially means Chocolatey will take any remote resources that a public package uses (such as installers), and it will download them locally to create another NuGet package you can use. By default, the resources are relocated into the “tools” directory of the NuGet package. Here I will show a simple example of internalizing the ownCloud client. As you can see in the output, the recompiled package is available in the C:\Example directory:

Now, if we compare the ChocolateyInstall.ps1 file from the public repository to the internalized package we just created, we can see the difference. The internalized package points to the local installer instead of the ownCloud URL, but the checksum is the same:

Public package:

Internalized package:

Internalizing multiple Chocolatey packages

Let’s say I have a group of packages I want to internalize. In this example, they’re Google Chrome, Git, LastPass, and Notepad++. A recent release of the Chocolatey Business version allows you to pass multiple packages with choco download:

Cool! Now we can just push the packages to our hosted repository:

Automating the checking and internalizing for new package versions

Now that we have a set of packages internalized, I want to take this a step further and automate internalizing any new version of a package if it is released on the Chocolatey repository, creating a very basic pipeline. There are a few ways to do this, but what I prefer is to use a virtual machine (VM) that will act as a testing machine for checking, installing, and internalizing new public packages. Set at a certain time interval, such as every 4 hours, this VM will run my script, which includes the command choco outdated. This command will see if any Chocolatey packages the machine installed are outdated based on the Chocolatey repository. If the VM finds certain packages have updated versions available, it will first internalize them, then install them to itself, and finally push them to our hosted NuGet server. Pretty cool!

To combine all of this, I created a PowerShell function Add-ChocoInternalizedPackage, which orchestrates this process. Here I will step through some of the code to show you what is happening. Please keep in mind this is a work in progress and currently does not work perfectly.

The parameter $APIKeyPath indicates that you have an encrypted file that has the API key of your internal Chocolatey repository. The first thing the function does is grab this key to use later on in choco push:

Here, we run choco outdated -r to get any out-of-date packages on our local machine. If any are found, we create a custom PowerShell object. The output of choco outdated needs to be parsed and formatted a bit since “|” is the delimiter, so we use the split method and place them into their own properties. Now, $NewPackages can be processed by the rest of the script.

We loop through the packages that need updating, but skip any packages with the name *.install that is also contained in the $NewPackages.Name object. The reason for this is that many packages such as “git” are actually virtual packages that just call *.install (example git.install). When using choco download, all packages including virtual and dependency packages are downloaded to be internalized, so “git.install” will still be internalized when the “git” package is processed. Skipping *.install packages will save us from redundancy. The $DownloadTime variable is used to filter all packages downloaded after this time, as you will see later.

This block of code attempts to internalize the package locally and save it to whatever path is in the $WorkingDirectory variable. Notice we check the $LASTEXITCODE variable to ensure that there were no errors in the choco download command. If $LASTEXITCODE is anything but zero (success), we add it to the $Failure array and move to the next package.

If internalization is successful, it attempts to install that package from the local Chocolatey package. And if the package installs correctly, it pushes all internalized packages created after the $DownloadTime variable (which again includes dependency and virtual packages) to your hosted repository with choco push, using the value of $RepositoryURL for your feed.

In terms of adding packages to the $Success and $Failure arrays, I chose to use Split-Path and remove the $WorkingDirectory from the value since that is not necessary for the user to see.

Finally, we write the contents of the successful and failed packages to the console. Optionally, you could put this into Send-MailMessage and email the results.

See it in action

Here is an example of the function running while it internalizes, installs, and pushes the “curl” package to my repository named “myfeed”. For testing purposes, I am not using https for the internal feed (which is highly recommended). To increase the size of the gif, please click on it.


As in any enterprise environment, you may want to vet the packages you are internalizing, although the Business version of Chocolatey does have some built-in security—such as Virus scanning (against installed A/V or VirusTotal)—not to mention all packages in the public repository go through a rigorous process of approval.

If you care to steal my code, you can do it here on Github .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *